Gmo philosophy essay

For this argument to work, one must assume that the gene strongly determines the development of a particular behavioral trait and that the person will be unable to avoid expressing that trait. Discuss the controversy of GMOs on an international scale and how this may impact the honey industry.

Such arguments are not readily accepted due to their metaphysical or theological overtones and dependence on essentialist idea of nature.

moral issues of gm crops

But global outrage ensued after group of Filipino farmers destroyed a test crop of golden rice. A different point of views exist among the scientific community and research is still in progress for exploring the long-term effects of GMOs Siegrist.

issue of genetically modified foods

Despite this reality, popular culture, the media, and politicians are apt to ignore the fact that strong genetic determinism is almost entirely a myth. Until productive discourse is established, barriers between opposing views will only strengthen.

genetically modified food

First, advances in behavioral genetics — the study of the genetic basis of behavior — suggest that genetic determinism may have implications for psychological determinism [ 39 ]. What is genetic modification?

Also, as we shall see below, worries about genetic determinism can reinforce concerns about psychological determinism [ 23 ]. Those who favor a ban, however, believe there is something inherently wrong with genetic modification, that there are inevitable, unavoidable, and undesirable consequences associated with modifying the human genome [ 16 ]. Cloning is inherently despotic, for it seeks to make one's children or someone else's children after one's own image or an image of one's choosing and their future according to one's will. The idea of a "genetic age" continues to exert a powerful influence on popular culture and many individuals regard genes as possessing nearly magical power, as well as moral and religious significance [ 38 ]. I beg to differ Sounds pretty amazing at first, right? For example, consider the claim "If you drop a rock, it will fall". Are GMO foods safe for our health?

Although the arguments are relatively the same, in discussing GM animals, the idea of a natural integrity or dignity seems more compelling. Although golden rice is a non-profit initiative, Shiva argues that it is a trojan horse to give GM crops a humanitarian face.

For example, the collision of an asteroid with the Earth is determined by the size, velocity, and orbit of both celestial bodies, along with certain other conditions. In some cases, the despotism may be mild and benevolent. For this argument to work, one must assume that the gene strongly determines the development of a particular behavioral trait and that the person will be unable to avoid expressing that trait. Moreover, since genes often produce more than one phenotypic effect a condition known as pleiotropy , we may find it difficult to maximize intelligence without simultaneously causing adverse affects, such as anxiety and aggression [ 41 , 42 ]. Messenger In this fourth instalment of GM in Australia — a series looking at the facts, ethics, regulations and research into genetically modified crops — Christopher Mayes examines ethical issues surrounding GM foods. If you have been given a gene for musical talent, you have no choice but to become a musician. These may include harms to children and to future generations; loss of biological or cultural diversity; economic costs; and the degradation of social values such as acceptance of disabled people, respect for the value of human life, and equality of opportunity. The sheer complexity necessarily entailed by hundreds of interrelated genes might, in this hypothetical scenario, hinder and forever frustrate our attempts to control or modify intelligence by way of genetic manipulation. Dozens or even hundreds of genes may play a causal role in the genesis of complex traits such as intelligence, personality, or athletic ability. A person with a gene for musical talent will face enormous pressure to become a musician. What if the truth of the matter was that people really had no idea what was in the food they were eating? These concerns need to be looked at by all of society since we are the ones who are directly affected by these choices. Food choice is among the important decisions of our daily life, and thus consumers have the right to know what they are choosing to eat. What can you do to make the world a better place by explaining what GMOs do to the human body, and why we should be growing our own food and purchasing foods at farmers markets?
Rated 10/10 based on 114 review
Lisa Heldke, Pragmatist Philosophical Reflections on GMOs